CLIMATE activists say that the argument for refusing a coal mine proposed for Whitehaven is "overwhelming" due to a declining demand for coking coal.
Supporters and opposition groups are engaging in last minute lobbying as decision time looms for the Woodhouse Colliery development.
If given the greenlight, the mine proposed for Whitehaven would be used to extract metallurgical coal for production of steel.
The final decision rests with Secretary of State for Levelling-Up, Housing and Communities Michael Gove, rather than the planning authority, as the development was called-in due to controversy around its climate impact.
READ MORE: Top steel boss - demand argument for Whitehaven coal mine 'doesn't stack up'
Following a contentious public inquiry, Mr Gove has been given a deadline of July 7 to make his decision and the rumour mill suggests he is minded to approve it.
However, Friends of the Earth have said he must show the coal mine the red light.
Friends of the Earth energy campaigner, Tony Bosworth, said: "The evidence for rejecting this mine is overwhelming. It would increase carbon emissions, its market is already starting to decline, and it won’t replace Russian coal imports. We need a green economy and the new jobs this brings, and areas like West Cumbria must be at the heart of this."
They argue that a maximum of 13 per cent of the coal will be used by the UK steel industry.
It comes after Chris McDonald, CEO of the Materials Processing Institute reported that the mine will have just two customers in the UK with one casting doubt on whether it could use any of the product due to its sulphur content.
But Mayor of Copeland Mike Starkie said: "British Steel will make decisions on buying the coal on a commercial basis. The simple fact is the mine project is being delivered by private investment funds, investors invest to make a return on their outlay and are clearly confident in the project and its potential markets to deliver positive returns on investment."
The mayor has been a supporter of the mine throughout the planning process.
He said: "The mine has gone through a rigorous process and I fully expect it to get the go ahead in the coming weeks because that is the right decision."
READ MORE: Friends of the Earth make fresh arguments in Whitehaven coal mine row
Supporters of the mine argue that it would mean a reduction in carbon emissions in the long-term as Cumbrian coal would be used in the production of British steel, rather than shipping the product from abroad.
But Friends of the Earth said: "The chairman of the Climate Change Committee has written that opening the Cumbrian mine would increase global carbon emissions and have an appreciable impact on the UK’s legally-binding carbon budgets. UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres recently said that opening new fossil fuel infrastructure would be “moral and economic madness."
Opposition groups argue that over 6,000 green jobs are on offer in Cumbria through new renewable energy developments.
But supporters of the mine say that clean energy proposals, such as nuclear reactors, would require steel produced with metallurgical coal.
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules hereLast Updated:
Report this comment Cancel